ThinkFacility Sign in
  1. Home
  2. News
  3. AI policy

States at UN talks adopt a two-year autonomous weapons mandate that campaigners call watered down

Over 95 states backed a treaty during the week, but a handful weakened the text in the final hours.

The countries that belong to the UN's Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons met in Geneva from November 16 to 20, 2026, to decide what to do about weapons that pick and attack targets on their own. They left with a two-year mandate. It doesn't commit them to binding rules.

Stop Killer Robots, the coalition that has pushed for a treaty since 2013, put out its verdict at the close on November 21. It says states "adopted a watered-down mandate that fails to chart a clear path towards a legally binding instrument."

Where
Palais des Nations, Geneva
When
16 to 20 November 2026
Parties
128 High Contracting Parties
Mandate
two-year
States backing a treaty
over 95, per Stop Killer Robots

What happened in the room

Much of it happened behind closed doors, which is why the record is thin. The coalition says most discussions excluded observers and civil society, so it couldn't report what states said or how they voted. It calls the conference shambolic.

Its account of the end goes like this. Over 95 states said during the week that they supported a treaty. Then, in the final hours, a small number of states weakened the mandate, "introducing uncertainty about the legal status of the final document." The release doesn't name them.

Autonomous weapons technology, including AI in the targeting cycle, is being deployed on the battlefield – delaying the creation of a legally binding instrument puts civilians and humanity at risk.

From Autonomous weapons talks fall short of addressing the urgent need for a treaty, says head of Stop Killer Robots – Stop Killer Robots

That's Nicole van Rooijen, the coalition's executive director. Verity Coyle of Human Rights Watch called the outcome disappointing in the same release, and pointed out that 163 countries had voted at the UN General Assembly for a resolution backing binding rules.

What was on the table

Going in, there were two very different plans. Peru's Ambassador Schialer Salcedo, chairing the committee on this question, proposed that the expert group negotiate a new protocol to the convention over two years and hand a draft to the 2028 meeting of its members. Stop Killer Robots welcomed that, though it wanted one year.

The United States wanted something slower. According to the coalition's reading of the US working paper, it asked for five more years of talks toward a non-binding instrument, with a report due at the next review conference in 2031. The coalition called that an unacceptable outcome.

The mandate that passed is two years long, so the time frame looks closer to Peru's plan. What the coalition disputes is whether it still leads to a protocol states must follow. Without the adopted text (the conference page lists only drafts so far), I can't settle that.

Why it matters past Geneva

The convention runs on consensus, and it's the only forum where the countries building these weapons sit down together. A binding protocol would be law for the states that join it. A non-binding one would be guidance, or as the coalition put it before the meeting, "Non-binding prohibitions and restrictions are just requests."

Human Rights Watch told the conference on November 18 why it thinks the existing laws of war fall short. Its statement puts the gap plainly.

Existing international humanitarian law remains vital, but it was never designed to deal with weapons systems that can select and engage targets without meaningful human control.

From Statement on Lethal Autonomous Weapons Systems to the CCW Seventh Review Conference | Human Rights Watch

Who that affects is civilians in a war zone, and soldiers on either side of an algorithm. On November 17 we covered tests from Vals in which AI models marked civilians as military targets, and Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent's account of Trump and Xi agreeing to keep humans in major military AI decisions. Neither is a rule anyone has to follow.

The coalition has said what it'll do if the convention stalls. Before the meeting, it wrote that states backing binding rules "must find other routes to do so", pointing to past disarmament treaties negotiated without every country at the table.

For now the work goes back to the expert group, and its two-year mandate runs to 2028.

More on AI policy

All AI policy stories